
World Rugby have handed down two 6-week bans to coaches for match official abuse and serious misconduct around public commentary in recent weekends.
Hames suspended
Hong Kong China Rugby coaching staff member Kane Hames has been issued a six-match suspension for verbal abuse of match officials during the World Rugby Nations Cup match against USA in Bourg-en-Bresse on 8 November. He was performing water carrier duties, was heard several times on live broadcast using offensive language directed at the officials. In line with the provisions of the Match Official Abuse Sanction Process, he is banned from all match-day activity, including being present in the stadium, for the duration of the suspension.
Erasmus 6 week ban
South Africa head coach, Rassie Erasmus also received 6 weeks international suspension for his comments following the Springboks match in France last Friday, and ahead of their match in Ireland this coming weekend. His comments covered incidents from their match, and about an incident in Ireland’s match relating to player suspensions. The World Rugby Match Official Abuse committee, chaired by senior officer Adam Casselden SC (Australia) determined that the threshold for serious misconduct had been met and that it “conduct “clearly amounts to disrespecting the authority of the match officials by impugning their integrity.”
Streamlined MO Sanction Process
Under World Rugby’s Match Official Abuse Sanction Process launched in July, an independent panel comprising a senior judicial officer as chair and two experienced judicial panel members considers whether conduct or comments by team personnel meet the threshold for sanction. Outcomes range from “no further action” to a guidance letter, formal warning or automatic sanction under the process.
The process runs in parallel with existing misconduct provisions under Regulation 18 and recognises World Rugby’s social media protection programme for match officials and players. Since 2023, the programme has shown that a large proportion of social media abuse begins with inaccurate comments on refereeing performance by those in positions of authority and influence.
Previously, the process was conducted purely under Regulation 18 and took months to come to fruition. For example, Erasmus’ previous case from the B&I Lions tour, for which he received a 10month ban, took place in July 2021 with disciplinary hearings in October and November that year. Erasmus was also suspended for 2 months in two-match ban in November 2022 for social media posts about Wayne Barnes.
No match day involvements or media duties
Both coaches could take their cases to a full disciplinary hearing if they chose to. The suspensions apply with immediate effect. According to World Rugby, the ban “applies to international matches, and includes any match-day involvement including coaching, direct or indirect contact with team management or players on match days; entering the stadium, coaches’ box, playing enclosure, technical area, approaching and/or communicating with match officials on match day; engaging in any ‘feedback’ process with match officials; and engaging in media duties during the suspension.”
Respect and respectful debate
The World Rugby statement adds, “Respect is fundamental to rugby, and match officials are central to the sport. Protecting their wellbeing and integrity, and their right to perform without abuse or intimidation, is a responsibility World Rugby and unions take seriously. Coaches, players, unions and everyone in the game must uphold these standards.
“Robust, respectful debate is natural, but teams have access to well-established and supported channels and protocols for raising officiating matters before and after matches. Challenging a decision is not the same as questioning an official’s integrity or making comments that expose them to personal abuse.”
Be the first to comment